Exodus 38:21-40:38

Why Keep Repeating?

 

A short comment on a short Torah reading, Pekudei:

 

In general, rabbinic interpreters (and some of their predecessors) shied away from recognizing any cases of repetition in the biblical text. “Every word counts” meant that no verse, or even part of a verse, could be understood as repeating something that had already been said. So, for example, when the prophet Isaiah had a vision of the seraphim surrounding the heavenly throne and calling to one another, “Holy, holy, holy is the Lord of hosts [of angels],” each of those holies was attributed with a different meaning. “Holy in the heights of heaven, His dwelling-place; holy on earth, where He performs His powerful acts; holy for all eternity.”

 

In the light of this approach, this week’s reading, along with the preceding one, seem a bit strange. They repeat (often word for word) what had already been said in the preceding weekly readings, which describe in great detail the desert tabernacle (mishkan) that the Israelites are to make and the priestly garments that are to be fashioned for the kohanim (priests) to wear. The only difference is that in those preceding readings, God tells Moses what the Israelites are to do in the future, whereas now the Torah reports that they carried out those instructions to the letter. But surely this could have been communicated in a single sentence: “And the Israelites did exactly as they had been instructed.” Why go through each and every item a second time, saying for each that the Israelites had in fact done as they were told?

 

One might think the lesson being imparted is similar to that of the book of Ecclesiastes (Kohelet) 7:8: “The end of something is better than its beginning; so too is patience better than arrogance.” But what does that mean?

 

“The end of something” refers to a project that has been completed, whereas “its beginning” is precisely that, the project when it was still in the planning stage. Anyone can start planning to do something, but what counts is the job once completed. So too with the mishkan and the priestly clothing, what mattered was not the set of plans, but the finished product. This being the case, Ecclesiastes says, patience—the willingness to wait and see things to their conclusion—is the right approach; arrogance and impatience will eventually sputter out.

 

Truthfully, however, it seems that the message of the repetitions in regard to the mishkan and priestly garments is somewhat different. In fact, that message is not particularly elusive. The instructions for making the mishkan and the garments are, in a sense, a model of the Torah as a whole. The Torah is full of commandments, and the point is that carrying them out to the letter is what gives Israel the opportunity to come before God—to stand, in the most real sense, in His mishkan, His very presence. That is why carrying out those commandments is, and always has been, the very essence of Judaism—and why the repetitions in this week’s reading are so important.

 

Shabbat shalom!